Hillary Clinton is flanked by John Edwards and Barack Obama during Monday’s Democratic presidential debate. (AP Images)
A new era of political debate began Monday night when the eight Democratic presidential candidates faced questions posted by citizens on YouTube. In the debate held at The Citadel in Charleston, S.C., and hosted by CNN???s Anderson Cooper, candidates faced a range of questions on subjects such as personal ethics, health care, gay rights, aid for Africa, education, global warming and the most compelling topic, what to do about Iraq.
The spectrum of questioners was also broad, ranging from college students to a Baptist minister to a lesbian couple looking to get married to parents of military members to a pair of rednecks from Tennessee, among others. Cooper said about 3,000 questions were uploaded to the user-generated site.
A YouTube user named Chris from Portland started the debate with an instruction rather than a question. He urged the candidates to “not beat around the Bush” and give straight answers that addressed each question. Cooper, who preceded the first question by saying he was “not sure exactly how it???s going to work”, did his best to keep the candidates on topic, but as the debate progressed it turned out much like any other, with the politicians doing whatever they could with the time given to promote their records. There was little chance for any rebuttal or protracted discourse on any single topic because of the number of topics that needed to be touched on and the large number of candidates on stage.
The most interesting moments centered on the three candidates best known to the public: Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and John Edwards.
When one viewer asked if she would describe herself as a “liberal”, Clinton said she would not, preferring the term “modern progressive”. She said she hoped to “find ways to help those who may not have all the advantages in life to get the tools they need to lead a more productive life”. Clinton, whose 2/1 odds to be the next U.S. president place her as the favorite according to the Bodog Sportsbook, was also asked if she has concerns about her gender would be received by leaders around the world. Her response earned applause from the audience when she said she is determined “to break that hardest of glass ceilings”.
Obama earned rousing applause when he said South Carolina needs more money for its schools, calling one district in Florence, S.C., a “corridor of shame.” When asked to address criticism that he is not “black enough”, Obama deadpanned, “When I???m catching a cab in Manhattan in the past, I???ve given my credentials.”
Edwards had the most difficult time, facing strong questions about his stances against gay marriage, as well as the only question not directed by the viewers. Cooper asked him about his wife???s assertion in the press that he and not Clinton was the best candidate for women???s rights. Edwards said he has fought for women???s health care and to raise the minimum wage. On gay marriage, he said he has “enormous personal conflict on this issue”, because his faith tells him one thing and his libertarian political views lean another way.
In the end, Clinton best demonstrated the hallmark qualities of a leader, detailing the difficulties of diplomacy with world leaders who are not allies and of the not-so-easy fix of troop withdrawal from Iraq.
The YouTube/CNN partnership will happen again in September when Republican candidates debate.
Odds to win the Democratic nomination to represent the party for the 2008 presidential election:
Hillary Clinton - 5/9
Barack Obama - 2/1
Al Gore - 5/1 (not present at debate and has not declared his candidacy)
John Edwards - 8/1
Dennis Kucinich - 20/1
Joe Biden - 30/1
Chris Dodd - 40/1
Mike Gravel - 40/1
Bill Richardson - 40/1
Field (any other candidate) - 50/1
For complete political odds related to the 2008 presidential race, visit the Bodog Sportsbook.